In a world where casting can make or break a film, I See Buildings Fall Like Lightning emerges as a testament to the power of talented young actors. This British-Irish drama, directed by Clio Barnard, showcases an impressive ensemble led by Anthony Boyle, Joe Cole, Jay Lycurgo, Daryl McCormack, and Lola Petticrew. Their performances are the true stars of the show, elevating the film beyond its inconsistently persuasive narrative.
The story revolves around a group of working-class friends from Birmingham, England, facing the challenges of adulthood in an economically depressed city. It's a quintessentially British tale of gritty realism, class consciousness, and masculine despair, with a healthy dose of melodrama. While the film's message is clear, its execution leaves something to be desired.
The Power of Performance
What makes this film truly captivating is the liquid, nervous energy that the core quintet brings to the screen. Their performances are interlocking and seamless, creating a sense of camaraderie and affection that feels genuine. Boyle and Petticrew, in particular, shine as Patrick and Shiv, a couple struggling to make ends meet while caring for their children and Shiv's elderly mother. Their Northern Irish accents, perfectly executed despite not being from the Midlands, add an intriguing layer to their characters.
A Choppy Narrative
However, the film's narrative struggles to maintain the same level of excellence. Adapted from a novel by Keiran Goddard, the screenplay by Enda Walsh sometimes falls flat, with jarring transitions and a lack of finesse. The polyphonic symphony of first-person monologues, a hallmark of Goddard's novel, is challenging to translate onto the screen, resulting in a choppy rhythm as we jump between characters.
The time-lapse construction of Conor's apartment complex, mirroring the demolition footage, is an interesting visual device. It serves as a subtle reminder of the passage of time and the changing landscape of the city. Yet, it also highlights the film's diagrammatic nature, almost foretelling the tragic fate that awaits these characters.
Exploring Masculine Angst
One aspect that stands out is the exploration of masculine despair and angst. Each character, in their own way, grapples with feelings of inadequacy and the weight of societal expectations. Conor, played by McCormack, is a simmering pot of rage, struggling with forces beyond his control. Oli, on the other hand, portrayed by Lycurgo, is sweet-natured but battles major addictions. Rian, embodied by Cole, is similarly hampered by inarticulacy and unspoken depths.
What many people don't realize is that these struggles are often intertwined with class consciousness and the economic realities of their lives. The film hints at a personal betrayal, a snake in the imaginary Eden of their past paradise, which adds an intriguing layer of complexity to the narrative.
A Community of Solidarity
Despite their differences, the five friends maintain a sense of solidarity. This is achieved through the physicality of their interactions, a result of improvisation and spontaneity on set. The ease with which they dance and touch each other is a testament to the fraternal bond they've built. It's a beautiful portrayal of male friendship, a rare glimpse into a world where men can be vulnerable and supportive.
A Haunting Conclusion
As the film reaches its conclusion, we are left with a sense of impending tragedy. The first scene sets the tone, with the characters partying as if their lives depend on it. We know that one of them will succumb to the dying of the light, and the funeral wake will inevitably follow. It's a haunting and powerful message about the fragility of life and the impact of economic depression on a community.
Final Thoughts
I See Buildings Fall Like Lightning is a film that leaves a lasting impression, not just because of its compelling story, but because of the talented actors who bring it to life. While the narrative has its flaws, the performances are truly outstanding. It's a film that explores the complexities of masculinity, class, and friendship, leaving us with a deeper understanding of the human condition. Personally, I think it's a must-watch for anyone interested in powerful storytelling and exceptional acting.
